Ok updating the forever thread.
I promised some info based on the testing of new handle bars on during the V20 build. Here's the summary info pictures to follow.
We tested:
Bullhorn brifters
Midge on-one
Salsa Woodchipper
Salsa Cowchipper 2
Legacy Gary Bars
We combined that with the Straight Slider and the Curved Slider; we tested it with the Slammed stem and the normal stem.
That was a lot of combos; and I didn't do the best job photographing it; it sort of went fast and it's hard to get good shots of them on the bike. Here are the key findings.
1) The height of the handle bars still has a lot to do with the bar selection
2) I'm 5'9" 170lbs headed back to 155 from 200+. I can
a) Ride the Straight Slider on and uncut (unslammed) stem, if the bars have some sort of drop to them either: traditional drops so bullhorns that have drop shoulders.
b) Ride the curved slider on the unslammed stem
c) Ride the straight slider on the slammed stem
d) I can not ride a slammed stem and a curved slider (well I can but it wouldn't really be safe there not enough room to sit up cleanly).
3) Pluckyblond is 5'7" of undisclosed weight but we'll call her slim. She can
a) Ride the Curved slider on an unslammed stem + bars with a drop
b) Ride Curved slider on a slammed stem with any bars
c) She can not ride comfortably with the straight slider and get two hand positions.
4) For me I have the follow handlebar issues:
a) WoodChippers are too narrow at the bend where I want the brifters, they end up hiting my legs
b) The cowchipper2 has too little forward reach and my arms are very bent at all positions
c) Gary bars are ok just a hair narrow but I've used those a long time.
d) Bullhorn brifters work good are very low have the right reach but only one position is usable. I would use them if Time Trialing but I think I'd ditch the brifters and go with blips for shifting and TT brakes. That would be more aero.
e) The Midge on-one is perfect; hair wider than the Garybars; a little less flare out and no need to cut them. The midge can also be run in a "up" position or for TTing it can be rotated down in the way Hardy has Moose configured and get a great position for aero. This is nice as there is no bar to change out.
5) Pluckyblond found this:
a) Midge too much reach would have to bring the slider way back into her body for arms to reach; leading to unstable steering and trouble getting off the bike.
b) Legacy Gaybars same proble as Midge.
c) Salsa Woodchipper really good; lets her get brifters really nice and straight forward. But on the Vendetta the hands are too high. These then got move to her Silvio and they work acceptable there. (This is a concession to all the people we have come test ride; her Silvio is our last one and her Bullhorn Brifters were too compact and hard to handle for people to test ride. She prefers them; but is content with the Woodchipper because the bike pretty much lives on the trainer now Call Bullhorn Brifters Choice 1A and Woodchipper 1B.)
e) Cowchipper2 was perfect for her with the slammed stem; the short reach of the bars give her a low aero position when on the hoods; and a nice tucked power position in the drops
6) In the end the key items become:
a) Does the reach give you two positions on the hood aero and in the drops power
b) can the bars be positioned low enough for your shoulder
c) which way does the bend in the bar flare the brifters
e) are the bars wide enough for you legs without being too wide and providing too much leverage.
Conclusions:
1) The Curved slider was a great idea and it solves problems for many the smaller riders.
2) The new boom design of the V20 series solves a lot of fit problems.
3) The Midge on-one is a great bar for riders over 5'8" and up
4) The Salsa cowchipper2 is great for smaller riders with shorter arm reach
5) The Salsa woodchipper is a middle group and good if you like your hand high when on the hoods.
6) Bullhorn brifters are still good but might now be a compromise you don't have to make because of the Curved slider.
Again photos of the final results to follow.