post-operation
The kit arrived, and quickly! Many thanks to Maria for that (Or at least that's who the fedex system said dispatched it).
I had a few minor issues with the conversion:
1. seatpost change. the old one was 30.2mm and normal (with integrated clamp) seatposts seem to be not compatible with the supplied clamp, so a trip to the reuse/recycle center found an old straight steel one (and extra set of handlebars for $6 total!). The 27.2mm steel post was then shimmed it up solidly with some thin aluminium. It seems solid enough and will do for the moment until I get a proper alu post to fit the frame and supplied seat clamp.
2. fork. I actually put the old red suspension fork and nice short stem on a different mountain bike I have, which had only a disc brake on the back, as I had a spare disc brake in the parts box for the front, so now that bike has discs front and rear. The fork from that bike (an old green ti-spring manitou, great fork but no disc mounts, hence the desire to swap) had clearance issues with the steel cruz front conversion brackets, so (musical chairs!) took the steel fork off the xtracycle and now all good, no front suspension but lighter than a suspension fork and there's still the big swingarm under my rear.
3. cables. The old cables were manky, so replaced most of them, and all housings. Cables and particularly gear shift cable housings are not as cheap as I expected!
4. bottom bracket. The donor bike BB was dead (right side bearing disintegrated) and very hard to remove (even after I googled to confirm which side is left hand thread!) but not a problem overall, as all the actual components on the conversion are old shimano xtr from a second old mountain bike with old shimano (pre-cartridge bearing era - how old?), and that bottom bracket is fine as well as much lighter.
The final conversion: 17.5kg (not a light bike! but that swingarm is probably valuable just for the weight of scrap aluminium it contains!).
I measured the weight distribution (with rider on board): 57% front, 43% rear. This seems close to Mr Tolhurst's guidelines, and maybe I will set it a few % less on the front (seemed rather front heavy when braking down the driveway) when I get comfortable enough riding it to lay the seat down more. The seat comfort and hand position seem good for now. Knee clearance also seems ok.
I rode slowly down the driveway (probably steeper than all "first ride" recommendations!) ok. Tooled carefully around on the street with some failure (the bike would get this funny lean and "not answer the helm" as boaties might say) and some success. It had just gone dark and just wanted a quick trial, in a couple of minutes I could manage pedalling with what I'll call "approximate" direction control.
I'm looking forward to more (and better!) riding.
I also can think of a nice big rack design to perhaps put on the back (As those toptube stickers always say "my other bike is an xtracycle...") which could triangulate from a fixed point made by old quick release fitted through the old bottom bracket shell, and a mount at the seatpost, with triangulating bridging elements from the BB up to the rear of the rack outboard either side of the swingarm - a benefit of this bike's non-URT suspension. Perhaps a big wide flat deck with a bit of a rail around the edge for tie-downs, or just a simple light basket concept, or something. Using QR through the old BB shell, and one around the seatpost could make the whole rack easy to put on or off when needed or not.
Things I'd like to improve:
1. weight. 3kg more than sofrider's advertised weight (and no kickstand yet). Feeling the weight of the steel front drive conversion brackets in my hand, I can see how the softrider's dedicated fork could save weight (as does their clearly lighter rear triangle compared to my "let's use a large chunk of aluminium" swingarm.). Not really anything that can be changed though, as the components are not to blame, it's just my low quality, heavy donor frame.
2. no kickstand, and nowhere easy to mount one. And the bike does not like to lean quietly against walls. If I go the QR-though the old BB shell route as mentioned above, I may use some right angle bracket to make a kickstand mounting point there.
3. Fenders. Call me slow, but I prefer the road grime not to be sprayed onto me. The funky reversed fork and swingarm are going to require some non-orthodox mounting solutions (or just ride the fenderly unchallenged bike when it rains).
Big thanks to John T and the Parkers for the great design and quality of the kit and quick service! Heres to many comfy miles!