I have a question about cleat position.
I have been riding for years with sandals with the cleat as far toward the back of the foot as I can get it without modifying the shoe. The cleats are between the ball and the arch. I was using elliptical rings on my previous bike. I am using circular rings on this bike.
Yesterday and today, I rode with my old mountain biking shoes. The cleats are farther forward. On the recumbent it feels like they are a little bit in front of the ball of the foot. I think they feel like they are under the ball of the foot on my mountain bike.
I felt like I could climb better. (All my climbs are short (less 4 minutes. Usually less than 2 minutes.) More ankling allowing a higher cadence? Recruiting more or different muscles?
However, in almost perfect weather and road surface conditions, I was only a few seconds ahead of last week’s time on the TT and last week I lost time to the wind and water over the road. I was 40 seconds slower than 3 weeks ago in similar weather conditions when I was testing the route the week before week 1.
With my ankle joint lower (call it 2cm), it feels like having a lower bottom bracket. With the pedal closer to the toes, I need to engage more muscle to transfer the force from my ankle (leg) to the pedals. I think both of these factors exposed weakness in muscle groups that I haven’t been using as much as I needed to today.
With training, will I be able to get my speed back up? Or, do I need to move the cleats closer to mid foot to have any chance of getting the same performance?
Generally, what is the effect of the fore-aft positioning of the cleats? Is there a “best”? Or is it an everybody is different? Or, does it just take some hours of training for a new position to feel natural?
Before you ask, I am giving my riding sandals to my son for when he is riding my trike and we are riding together (at least until he outgrows them). So I got out my rarely used MTB shoes for myself. I don’t know if I can move the cleats on these shoes as they have been in the same place for 20 years. If I do move them, I would have to move them back on the rare occasions when I do ride my MTB in order to avoid tire-toe interference.
The answer might be a new pair of shoes or sandals for me, but I am curious to try to understand the contrast of feeling that I could power up the hills (2-4 minute effort) better but that my 36+ minute effort was less effective. And I am hoping to learn from your collective wisdom so that I don’t have to do a long series of experiments.
Thanks,
Brad